Climate change is a human rights issue – and that's how we can solve it 24/04/2012, 11:22:52 PM (GMT+7)

(Guardian)-Global climate-change talks often resemble the scene of a traffic accident. Multiple voices shout each other down in a bid to tell their own version of events. What is the real damage, how quickly must it be repaired, and who should foot the bill?

deforestation in Sumatra

Human rights issue ... deforestation in Sumatra. Photograph: Ulet Infansasti/AFP/Getty

But the real concern is not that the debate is congested and gridlocked; it is that the current clamour masks a deeper failing, namely to identify an honest starting point. In Prosperity Without Growth, the economist Tim Jackson convincingly expounds the myth of "absolute decoupling" of emissions from economic growth. The growth of emissions can be slowed, relative to the growth rate of the economy. However, emissions cannot conceivably be stalled or reversed while the economy continues to expand, however great the carbon-saving technologies of the coming years.

If our political processes cannot conceive of a non-growth future, and yet a fundamental rethink of growth is the only honest starting point for the fight against climate change, then those political processes are clearly not fit for purpose.

Does this mean that democracy has failed, and must be sacrificed for authoritarian solutions? The solution may in fact be the polar opposite. A system where failing governance procedures are forced to think long-term does not necessarily require anti-democratic "climate tzars". Instead, this revolution can be hyper-democratic and guided by human rights.

Climate change represents an enormous threat to a whole host of human rights: the right to food, the right to water and sanitation, the right to development. There is therefore huge scope for human rights courts and non-judicial human rights bodies to treat climate change as the immediate threat to human rights that it is. Such bodies could therefore take government policy to task when it is too short-sighted, too unambitious, or too narrowly focused on its own constituents at the expense of those elsewhere. Fossil fuel mining, deforestation, the disturbance of carbon sinks, and the degradation of the oceans are developments that can be blocked on human rights grounds.

Human rights bodies can, and must, increasingly play this reactive role at the local level, in order to ward off the multitude of developments that simultaneously violate human rights and aggravate climate change. But that will not suffice. They must also become proactive and holistic in warding off human rights violations, and by extension, the advance of climate change at the global level.

Where human rights deficits are detected, governments are required to put monitoring systems in place. They must also improve coordination within government, encourage the participation of all stakeholders – especially the most vulnerable – and define the responsibilities of institutions and set deadlines by which the human right in question must be met . In short, they must adopt multi-year strategies towards the fulfilment of human rights and increase the political cost of not moving fast enough.

This approach is, in fact, also ideal for tackling climate change. Underlying it is the idea that the market cannot move in the direction of sustainability without a framework providing the right incentives. According to the UNCTAD's World Investment Report 2010: Investing in a low-carbon economy, $400bn (£250bn) would be required every year between from 2010-2015 to make the shift to a low-carbon economy, and this figure could climb to £1,300bn a year by 2030.

Nothing less than a huge effort mobilising public investment and, through appropriate incentives, private funds, will be needed. This will not happen by chance. It can only happen by design. It requires a sustained effort across a number of years, to promote new, cleaner technologies in industry, to develop renewable sources of energy, and to shift to more sustainable consumption patterns. And it demands a comprehensive approach, to ensure for instance that governments which encourage renewable energy do not simultaneously outsource their food and energy production to palm oil plantations or soy-fed livestock farming, which drives deforestation in other parts of the world.

Human rights bodies must now invoke this approach and apply it directly to climate change, obliging governments to present them with long-term strategies that can achieve significant reductions in carbon emissions and move towards low-carbon societies.

Crucially, the legislative and executive branches would be obliged to adopt a strategy, but its precise content would not be prejudged. Meanwhile, human rights bodies would be acting well within their remit by requiring that any such strategy be at least in conformity with the international undertakings of the state.

By working in this direction, human rights bodies would help overcome the problems of delivering collective action that are currently an obstacle to the progress of the global warming negotiations held under the UNFCCC. They would move towards imposing a duty to cooperate, on the basis of the universal declaration of human rights.

Climate infrastructure needed Climate change and air pollution will combine to curb food supplies World breaks temperature record for June after hottest May New study investigates the impact of climate change on malaria Vietnam’s Mekong Delta responds to climate change
Other News
Who is responsible for climate change? Global warming makes drought come on earlier, faster, and harder Tackling climate change would grow global economy Third warmest May in satellite record might portend record-setting El Niño Why is climate communication so hard? ASEAN tourism sector commits to fighting climate challenge The claim of a 97% consensus on global warming does not stand up Where is the signboard to warn of a climate catastrophe? Americans care deeply about 'global warming' – but not 'climate change' 'Climategate' had only fleeting effect on global warming scepticism
Vietnam ignores scientists’ warnings about asbesto 31/07/2014, 10:18:20 AM (VietNamNet Bridge)-Despite the World Health Organization’s (WHO) strong warnings against the use of asbestos (chrysotile) and the ban of asbestos in many countries, Vietnam continues to use it because of its cheap costs.
Hydropower-plant officials offered false promises 31/07/2014, 10:17:12 AM (VietNamNet Bridge)-“We should not expect that hydropower plants can prevent floods for the lowlands. They can never do this. Floods will still come. We have to accept to live together with floods,” said Nguyen Tai Anh, deputy general director of the Electricity of Vietnam (EVN), the largest power group, the investor of many power plants and the only electricity retailer in Vietnam.
Climate infrastructure needed 31/07/2014, 10:16:09 AM (VNS/VNN)-Mega-cities and big cities have endured dangerous impact from climate change, but small- and medium-sized towns will suffer the most, according to experts.
Vietnam ranks in top ten software outsourcing prov 29/07/2014, 03:36:15 PM (VNA)-The Vietnamese software industry has been selected as one of the top-ten software outsourcing providers of the Asia Pacific region, radio The Voice of Vietnam (VOV) reported.
Garbage-collection groups in HCM City accused of e 29/07/2014, 03:29:33 PM (VietNamNet Bridge)-To get the right to collect garbage in some certain areas, the owners of garbage-collection cooperatives have to pay billions of dong to buy the “areas” from their predecessors. To offset these payments, they then charge local households high collection fees.
Most viewed
Khanh Hoa suffers factory pollution 28/07/2014, 02:13:55 PM (VNS)-Residents in the central coastal province of Khanh Hoa have been suffering from high levels of pollution caused by hundreds of unregistered manufacturers operating in populated areas, according to the Lao Dong (Labour) newspaper.
Climate change and air pollution will combine to curb food supplies 28/07/2014, 02:15:26 PM (Sciencedaily)-Many studies have shown the potential for global climate change to cut food supplies. But these studies have, for the most part, ignored the interactions between increasing temperature and air pollution -- specifically ozone pollution, which is known to damage crops.
Garbage-collection groups in HCM City accused of extortion 29/07/2014, 03:29:33 PM (VietNamNet Bridge)-To get the right to collect garbage in some certain areas, the owners of garbage-collection cooperatives have to pay billions of dong to buy the “areas” from their predecessors. To offset these payments, they then charge local households high collection fees.
Trees save lives, reduce respiratory problems 28/07/2014, 02:14:42 PM (Sciencedaily)-In the first broad-scale estimate of air pollution removal by trees nationwide, U.S. Forest Service scientists and collaborators calculated that trees are saving more than 850 human lives a year and preventing 670,000 incidents of acute respiratory symptoms.
Sugarcane firms suspended over pollution 29/07/2014, 03:27:51 PM (VNS)-The Viet Nam Environment Administration has decided to suspend the operation of two sugarcane companies for causing serious pollution.
© Copyright 2007-2011 Vfej.vn
Designed and developed by Ovem!Software
Management Agency: Vietnam Forum of Environmental Journalists
Address: 22/A2, Lane 49, Linh Lang Street, Ba Dinh District, Hanoi-Vietnam
Tel: (84-4) 37628933 - Fax: (84-4) 37628933
Publishing License: No. 513/GP-BC issued on 22/11/2007